Statement of Investment Principles
This Investment Statement sets out the principles governing decisions about investments for the Matthew
Algie and Company Limited Pension & Assurance Scheme (“the Scheme”) to meet the requirements of
The Pensions Act 1995, as amended by the Pensions Act 2004, The Occupational Pension Schemes
(Investment) Regulations 2005 and other subsequent amendments. It is subject to periodic review by the
Trustee at least every three years and more frequently as appropriate.
The Scheme’s investment strategy is derived from the Trustee’s investment objectives. The objectives
have been taken into account at all stages of planning, implementation and monitoring of the investment
strategy.
In preparing this Statement, the Trustee has consulted with the principal employer (Matthew Algie &
Company Limited) and has taken professional advice from their Investment Consultant (Isio Group
Limited/Isio Services Limited (‘Isio’)).
Governance
The Trustee of the Scheme makes all major strategic decisions including, but not limited to, the Scheme’s
asset allocation and the appointment and termination of investment managers.
When making such decisions, and when appropriate, the Trustee takes proper written advice. The
Trustee’s investment advisers, Isio, are qualified by their ability in, and practical experience, of financial
matters, and have the appropriate knowledge and experience. The investment advisers’ remuneration may
be a fixed fee or based on time worked, as negotiated by the Trustee in the interests of obtaining best
value for the Scheme.
Investment objective
The Scheme closed to new entrants and future benefit accrual on 31 August 2010.
The primary objective of the Scheme is to provide pension and lump sum benefits for the current members
on their retirement, and/or benefits on death, before or after retirement for their dependents, on a defined
benefit basis.
The Scheme’s present investment objective is to achieve a return of around 2.5 p.a. (based on Isio’s
central assumptions as at 30 June 2020) above the return on UK Government bonds (which are
considered to move in a similar fashion to the calculated value of the Scheme’s liabilities). Further detail on
the expected return on investments is provided in the Appendix A.
Page 2
The Trustee’s medium term objective is to reach and maintain a funding position of 100% of technical
provisions – such a target being consistent with the strength of the employer covenant and the Trustee’s
investment risk tolerance.
The Trustee and Company agreed a long term funding objective of reaching full funding on a Gilts plus
0.5% basis by 2028. The Trustee intends to reduce risk as funding improves to increase the certainty of
achieving this objective. In terms of the ultimate objective for the Scheme, the Trustee and Company
continue to target securing all Members’ benefits within an insurance contract (i.e. reach full funding on an
insurance buy-out basis). The Trustee also considers the Scheme’s funding position on other relevant
bases for valuation and accounting. Funding positions are monitored regularly by the Trustee and formally
reviewed at each triennial valuation, or more frequently as required by the Pensions Act 2004.
Investment strategy
The Trustee takes a holistic approach to considering and managing risks when formulating the Scheme’s
investment strategy.
The Scheme’s investment strategy was derived following careful consideration of the factors set out in
Appendix B. The considerations include the nature and duration of the Scheme’s liabilities, the risks of
investing in the various asset classes, the implications of the strategy (under various scenarios) for the
level of employer contributions required to fund the Scheme, and also the strength of the sponsoring
company’s covenant. The Trustee considered the merits of a range of asset classes.
The Trustee recognises that the investment strategy is subject to risks, in particular the risk of a mismatch
between the performance of the assets and the calculated value of the liabilities. This risk is monitored by
regularly assessing the funding position and the characteristics of the assets and liabilities. This risk is
managed by investing in assets which are expected to perform in excess of the liabilities over the long
term, and also by investing in a suitably diversified portfolio of assets with the aim of minimising (as far as
possible) volatility relative to the liabilities.
The assets of the Scheme consist predominantly of investments which are traded on regulated markets.
Investment Management Arrangements
At present, three investment managers have been appointed to manage the assets of the Scheme as
listed in the SIP. The investment managers are regulated under the Financial Services and Markets Act
2000.
All decisions about the day-to-day management of the assets have been delegated to the investment
managers via a written agreement. The delegation includes decisions about:
• Selection, retention and realisation of investments including taking into account all financially material
considerations in making these decisions;
• The exercise of rights (including voting rights) attaching to the investments;
Page 3
• Undertaking engagement activities with investee companies and other stakeholders, where
appropriate.
The Trustee takes investment managers’ policies into account when selecting and monitoring managers.
The Trustee also takes into account the performance targets the investment managers are evaluated on.
The investment managers are expected to exercise powers of investment delegated to them, with a view
to following the principles contained within this statement, so far as is reasonably practicable.
As the Scheme’s assets are invested in pooled vehicles, the custody of the holdings is arranged by the
investment managers.
Financially Material Considerations
The Trustee has considered financially material factors such as environmental, social and governance
(‘ESG’) issues as part of the investment process to determine a strategic asset allocation over the length
of time during which the benefits are provided by the Scheme for members. It believes that financially
material considerations (including climate change) are implicitly factored into the expected risk and return
profile of the asset classes they are investing in.
In endeavouring to invest in the best financial interests of the beneficiaries, the Trustee has elected to
invest through pooled funds. The Trustee acknowledges that it cannot directly influence the environmental,
social and governance policies and practices of the companies in which the pooled funds invest. However,
the Trustee does expect its fund managers and investment consultant to take account of financially
material considerations when carrying out their respective roles.
The Trustee accepts that the Scheme’s assets are subject to the investment managers’ own policies on
socially responsible investment. The Trustee will assess that these correspond with its responsibilities to
the beneficiaries of the Scheme with the help of its investment consultant.
An assessment of the ESG and responsible investment policies forms part of the manager selection
process when appointing new managers and these policies are also reviewed regularly for existing
managers with the help of the investment consultant. The Trustee will only invest with investment
managers that are signatories for the United Nations Principles of Responsible Investment (‘UN PRI’) or
other similarly recognised standard.
The Trustee will monitor financially material considerations through the following means:
• Obtain training where necessary on ESG considerations in order to understand fully how ESG
factors including climate change could impact the Scheme and its investments;
• Use ESG ratings information provided by its investment consultant, to assess how the Scheme's
investment managers take account of ESG issues; and
• Request that all of the Scheme's investment managers provide information about their ESG
policies, and details of how they integrate ESG into their investment processes, via its investment
consultant.
If the Trustee determines that financially material considerations have not been factored into the
investment managers’ process, it will take this into account when considering whether to select or retain an
investment.
Page 4
Stewardship
The Trustee’s policy on the exercise of rights attaching to investments, including voting rights, is that these
rights should be exercised by the investment managers on the Trustee’s behalf, having regard to the best
financial interests of the beneficiaries.
The investment manager should engage with companies to take account of ESG factors in the exercise of
such rights as the Trustee believes this will be beneficial to the financial interests of members of the long
term. The Trustee will review the investment managers’ voting policies, with the help of its investment
consultant, and decide if they are appropriate.
The Trustee also expects the fund manager to engage with investee companies on the capital structure
and management of conflicts of interest.
If the policies or level of engagement are not appropriate, the Trustee will engage with the investment
manager, with the help of its investment consultant, to influence the investment manager’s policy. If this
fails, the Trustee will review the investments made with the investment manager.
The Trustee has taken into consideration the Financial Reporting Council’s UK Stewardship Code and
expects investment managers to adhere to this where appropriate for the investments they manage.
Investment Manager Monitoring and Engagement
The Trustee monitors and engages with the Scheme’s investment managers and other stakeholders on a
variety of issues. Below is a summary of the areas covered and how the Trustee seeks to engage on these
matters with investment managers.
Areas for
engagement
Method for monitoring and engagement Circumstances for additional
monitoring and engagement
Performance,
Strategy and
Risk
• The Trustee receives a quarterly
investment performance report which
details information on the underlying
investments’ performance, strategy
and overall risks, which are
considered at the relevant Trustee
meeting.
• There are significant
changes made to the
investment strategy.
• The risk levels within
the assets managed by
the investment
managers have
increased to a level
above and beyond the
Trustee’s expectations.
• Underperformance vs
the performance
objective over the
period that this
objective applies.
Page 5
Environmental,
Social,
Corporate
Governance
factors and the
exercising of
rights
• The Trustee’s investment managers
provide annual reports on how they
have engaged with issuers regarding
social, environmental and corporate
governance issues (including those
concerning capital structure and
conflicts of interest).
• The Trustee receives information from
their investment adviser on the
investment managers’ approaches to
engagement.
• The manager has not
acted in accordance
with their policies and
frameworks.
• The manager’s policies
are not in line with the
Trustee’s policies in this
area.
Through the engagement described above, the Trustee will work with the investment managers to improve
their alignment with the above policies. Where sufficient improvement is not observed, the Trustee will
review the relevant investment manager’s appointment and will consider terminating the arrangement.
Realisation of investments
The Trustee operates a bank account for daily cash flow needs.
The significant majority of the Scheme’s investments may be realised quickly if required.
Additional voluntary contributions (AVCs)
Assets in respect of member’s AVCs are held with LGIM in investment vehicles chosen by the Trustee.
These vehicles have been closed to new contributions since 1 June 2006.
Agreed as final version on behalf Dalriada Trustees Limited as the Trustee of the Matthew Algie
and Company Limited Pension & Assurance Scheme.
Date: 28 September 2020
Date of Amendments
First Amendment: June 2004
Second Amendment: February 2008
Third Amendment: February 2016
Fourth Amendment: September 2019
Fifth Amendment: September 2020
Page 6
Appendix A
Asset split by asset class (as at 30 June 2020)
Investment
Manager
Asset Class
Strategic
Benchmark
(%)
Expected
Return1
(%)
LGIM
Global Equity 10.0 4.0
Long Lease
Property
10.0 2.5
Diversified Growth 10.0 3.5
Liability Driven
Investment
28.0 0.0
CQS Diversified Credit 20.0 2.6
JP Morgan Diversified Credit 10.0 1.5
Partners
Group2
Direct Lending 12.0 4.2
Total 100.0 2.5
1 Expected return assumptions quoted relative to Gilts and based on Isio’s central assumptions as at 30
June 2020.
2 The mandate is expected to be implemented over H2 2020.
Page 7
Appendix B – Risks, Financially Material Considerations and Non-Financial matters
A non-exhaustive list of risks and financially material considerations that the Trustee has considered and
sought to manage is shown below.
The Trustee adopts an integrated risk management approach. The three key risks associated within this
framework and how they are managed are stated below:
Risks Definition Policy
Investment The risk that the Scheme’s
position deteriorates due to the
assets underperforming.
• Selecting an investment objective
that is achievable and is consistent
with the Scheme’s funding basis and
the sponsoring company’s covenant
strength.
• Investing in a diversified portfolio of
assets.
Funding The extent to which there are
insufficient Scheme assets
available to cover ongoing and
future liability cash flows.
• Funding risk is considered as part of
the investment strategy review and
the actuarial valuation.
• The Trustee will agree an
appropriate basis in conjunction with
the investment strategy to ensure an
appropriate journey plan is agreed to
manage funding risk over time.
Covenant The risk that the sponsoring
company becomes unable to
continue providing the required
financial support to the
Scheme.
• When developing the Scheme’s
investment and funding objectives,
the Trustee takes account of the
strength of the covenant ensuring
the level of risk the Scheme is
exposed to is at an appropriate level
for the covenant to support.
The Scheme is exposed to a number of underlying risks relating to the Scheme’s investment strategy,
these are summarised below:
Risk Definition Policy
Interest rates and
inflation
The risk of mismatch between
the value of the Scheme
assets and present value of
liabilities from changes in
interest rates and inflation
expectations.
To hedge c.72% of the impact of interest
rate and inflation movements on the value of
the Scheme’s liabilities (measured on a flat
gilts basis)
Liquidity Difficulties in raising sufficient
cash when required without
adversely impacting the fair
market value of the
investment.
To maintain a sufficient allocation to liquid
assets so that there is a prudent buffer to
pay members benefits as they fall due
(including transfer values), and to provide
collateral to the LDI manager.
Market Experiencing losses due to
factors that affect the overall
performance of the financial
markets.
To remain appropriately diversified and
hedge away any unrewarded risks, where
practicable.
Credit Default on payments due as
part of a financial security
contract.
To diversify this risk by investing in a range
of credit markets across different
geographies and sectors.
Page 8
To appoint investment managers who
actively manage this risk by seeking to
invest only in debt securities where the yield
available sufficiently compensates the
Scheme for the risk of default.
Environmental,
Social and
Governance
Exposure to Environmental,
Social and Governance
factors, including but not
limited to climate change,
which can impact the
performance of the Scheme’s
investments.
To appoint managers who satisfy the
following criteria, unless there is a good
reason why the manager does not satisfy
each criteria:
1. Responsible Investment (‘RI’) Policy /
Framework
2. Implemented via Investment Process
3. A track record of using engagement and
any voting rights to manage ESG factors
4. ESG specific reporting
5. UN PRI Signatory
The Trustee monitors the managers on an
ongoing basis.
The Trustee considers ESG issues as part of
the investment process, and believes that
financially material considerations (including
climate change) are implicitly factored into
the expected risk and return profile of the
asset classes they are investing in.
Currency The potential for adverse
currency movements to have
an impact on the Scheme’s
investments.
Hedge all currency risk on all assets that
deliver a return through contractual income.
Hedge c. 50% of currency risk on equities.
Non-financial
matters
The views of the members
including (but not limited to)
their ethical views and their
views in relation to social and
environmental impact and
present and future quality of
life.
Non-financial matters are not taken into
account in the selection, retention or
realisation of investments.
Page 9
Appendix C - Policy on Investment Manager Arrangements
The Trustee has the following policies in relation to the investment management arrangements for the
Scheme:
How the investment managers are
incentivised to align their investment
strategy and decisions with the
Trustee’s policies.
• As the Scheme is invested in pooled funds, there
is not scope for these funds to tailor their strategy
and decisions in line with the Trustee’s policies.
However, the Trustee invests in a portfolio of
pooled funds that are aligned to the strategic
objective.
• The Trustee believes the annual fee paid to the
fund managers incentivises them to stick to the
fund objective, which is used to reflect the
investment strategy.
How the investment managers are
incentivised to make decisions based
on assessments of medium to longterm financial and non-financial
performance of an issuer of debt or
equity and to engage with them to
improve performance in the medium to
long-term.
• The Trustee reviews the investment managers’
performance relative to medium and long-term
objectives as documented in the investment
management agreements.
• The Trustee monitors the investment managers’
engagement and voting activity on an annual
basis as part of their ESG monitoring process.
• The Trustee does not incentivise the investment
managers to make decisions based on nonfinancial performance.
How the method (and time horizon) of
the evaluation of investment
managers’ performance and the
remuneration for their services are in
line with the Trustee’s policies.
• The Trustee reviews the performance of all of the
Scheme’s investments on a net of cost basis to
ensure a true measurement of performance
versus investment objectives.
• The Trustee evaluates performance over the time
period stated in the investment managers’
performance objective, which is typically 3 to 5
years.
• Investment manager fees are reviewed annually
to make sure the correct amounts have been
charged and that they remain competitive.
The method for monitoring portfolio
turnover costs incurred by investment
managers and how they define and
monitor targeted portfolio turnover or
turnover range.
• The Trustee does not directly monitor turnover
costs. However, the investment managers are
incentivised to minimise costs as they are
measured on a net of cost basis.
• The Trustee recognises that portfolio turnover
and associated transaction costs are a necessary
part of investment management and that the
impact of portfolio turnover costs is reflected in
performance figures provided by the investment
managers.
• The Trustee does not believe in setting a portfolio
turnover target – being the frequency with which
the assets are expected to be bought/sold –
because each investment manager’s style differs
in terms of level of frequent active management,
and therefore turnover, involved. The Trustee
believes transaction costs should be monitored
indirectly as one aspect of a holistic approach to
overall manager performance assessment.
Page 10
The duration of the Scheme’s
arrangements with the investment
managers
• The duration of the arrangements is considered
in the context of the type of fund the Scheme
invests in.
o For closed ended funds or funds with a lockin period the Trustee ensures the timeframe
of the investment or lock-in is in line with the
Trustee’s objectives and Scheme’s liquidity
requirements.
o For open ended funds, the duration is flexible
and the Trustee will from time-to-time
consider the appropriateness of these
investments and whether they should
continue to be held
Sign up to our
monthly newsletter
Receive free coffee industry insights, recipes and more straight to your inbox